515.218.7888 (Iowa) 469.200.4077 (Texas)
Case Briefs

Range of Motion Products, LLC v. Armaid Co.

166 F.4th 981 (Fed. Cir. 2026) · No. No. 2023-2427 · Decided February 2, 2026 · 2-1 · Cunningham, J. (Moore, C.J., Hughes, Cunningham, JJ.; Moore, C.J., dissenting) · No. 1:22-cv-00091-JDL, 2023 WL 5530768 (D. Me. Aug. 28, 2023), affirmed

Presented by Kyle Coleman

Range of Motion Products, LLC v. Armaid Co. — video case brief

How much of a design patent survives once its functional features are set aside? In Range of Motion Products, LLC v. Armaid Co., 166 F.4th 981 (Fed. Cir. 2026), a divided Federal Circuit panel, in an opinion by Judge Cunningham, affirmed summary judgment that the Armaid2 massager does not infringe U.S. Design Patent No. D802,155. The majority held that the district court properly construed the claim to identify the functional aspects of the design, including the clamshell shape of the arms, and that the remaining ornamental aspects of the two designs are plainly dissimilar. It rejected a side-by-side comparison of the designs that would bypass claim construction. Chief Judge Moore dissented, writing that the "plainly dissimilar" formulation from Egyptian Goddess shifts the inquiry from overall similarity to differences and takes a question of fact from the jury. Rehearing en banc was denied on August 11, 2026.

Read the opinion (PDF)

Transcript

Range of Motion Products v. Armaid, decided February 2nd, 2026. A divided panel of the Federal Circuit, in a precedential opinion by Judge Cunningham, affirmed summary judgment that a massage device did not infringe a design patent. The court held that a design patent claim is first construed to separate its functional aspects from its ornamental ones, and that, after doing so here, the two designs were plainly dissimilar. Chief Judge Moore dissented. Here's the brief.

Range of Motion Products owns the D'155 patent, a design patent titled "Body Massaging Apparatus" that issued in November 2017. Its own product, the Rolflex, embodies the design: two opposed, curved arms that carry rollers and join at a hinge.

Armaid sells the accused product, the Armaid2. Armaid had sold an earlier arm massager, the Armaid1, since the 1990s, and its owner held a utility patent, titled "Limb Massager," that the Armaid1 embodied.

Range of Motion first sued in the District of Maine in 2021 and, after the court denied a preliminary injunction, dismissed that suit. It sued again in April 2022. In construing the claim, the district court distinguished the features of the design that were functional from those that were ornamental. It concluded that many, but not all, of the design's features were driven by function, and that the claim's scope was accordingly narrow. It then held that no reasonable jury could find the Armaid2 substantially similar to the claimed design, and granted summary judgment of non-infringement.

Two questions were presented: whether the claim construction improperly eliminated structural elements of the design, in particular the shape of the arms, and whether, even under that construction, the designs were similar enough to reach a jury.

Infringement is judged by the ordinary observer test of Gorham v. White: whether, in the eye of an ordinary observer, giving such attention as a purchaser usually gives, the two designs are substantially the same. Under the en banc decision in Egyptian Goddess, where the claimed and accused designs are plainly dissimilar, the patentee fails as a matter of law.

On claim construction, the court agreed that the clamshell shape of the arms is functional. The earlier utility patent claimed arms shaped and dimensioned to clamp a limb, and Range of Motion's own marketing said that the clam-shaped arms provide significant leverage.

Range of Motion argued that the patent's drawings settled the matter, because the arms are drawn in solid lines. The court disagreed. A design element need not be wholly ornamental or wholly functional, and treating solid lines as dispositive would make every feature drawn in solid lines ornamental per se. Nor is the existence of alternative designs a threshold inquiry; it is one factor among several.

On infringement, the court rejected the argument that it is enough to lay pictures of the two designs side by side.

The district court had recognized that the designs look similar at a conceptual level, but found that most of those similarities were functional. It then identified ornamental differences, including a proportionally larger hinge apparatus and a segmented appearance in the Armaid2. Together, the district court found, those features gave the Armaid2 a stylized impression, in contrast to the robust and workmanlike impression of the patented design.

The court therefore affirmed. It added that a three-way comparison with the prior-art Armaid1 would support the same result.

Chief Judge Moore dissented. In her view a reasonable jury could find the two designs substantially the same, and that question of fact belonged to the jury. She wrote that Egyptian Goddess had, without the court realizing it, changed the inquiry from the similarity of the overall designs to their differences.

She would have vacated and remanded for the district court to reconsider summary judgment, focusing on the overall similarities, as Gorham requires, rather than on differences.

Range of Motion confirms that functionality limits a design patent at claim construction. A court may identify the functional aspects of elements the drawings claim, and the ordinary observer comparison is then confined to the ornamental aspects that remain. Similarity that follows from function does not, by itself, create a question for the jury. The court denied rehearing en banc on August 11th, 2026, with four judges dissenting from the denial.

Range of Motion Products, LLC v. Armaid Co., 166 F.4th 981, decided February 2nd, 2026. I'm Kyle Coleman. Thanks for watching.

These videos are educational case briefs, not legal advice, and watching them does not create an attorney-client relationship with the presenter or the firm. Case law and its interpretation evolves, always check a decision's subsequent history. Do not rely on these case briefs, but read the case yourself or have your attorney read them. Videos are presented via an AI avatar and voice clone of Kyle Coleman, created with his participation and consent.